Property
Casualty Insurance
Comprehensive Insurance Agency offers ALL forms of property and casualty insurance for your personal and business protection needs.
Homeowners
Insurance
Comprehensive Insurance Agency is an insurance provider with thriving business partnerships with several financially-sound local, regional and global companies.
A Modern
Approach to
Insurance
We take the time to find out what level of protection you need for your family and business, then we present options that work for you.
Auto
Insurance
You must have automobile insurance in New York, New Jersey, and most other states.




of experience

Your Trusted Partner in Insurance Solutions
25+
Carriers



Tell Us About You



Get a Custom Quote



Get Covered & Relax

Insurance Solutions Built for Life and Business
Home
Insurance
Car
Insurance
Flood
Insurance
Commercial
Insurance
Commercial
Auto



You Can Trust

We Go Beyond Insurance
Personalized Service
You're not just a policy number. We take the time to understand your needs and match you with the perfect plan.
Top-Rated Carriers
We partner with the industry’s most trusted names to offer reliable, competitive coverage options.
Fast & Friendly Support
Questions? Claims? Policy changes? Our team is just a call or click away—always ready to help.

Meet our professional team members
David Silva
Insurance SpecialistArjeta Bokshi
Insurance AgentPaula Hyland
Customer Service SpecialistJean Held
Client Relations LeadRosanna Magno
Human ResourcesNicole Bellas
Commercial Lines ProducerGiovanni "John" Magno
PrincipalNicholas "Nick" Donato Jr.
PartnerMatthew Lasala
Insurance ProfessionalMariel Lisanti
Customer Service RepresentativeMichele Donato
Business AnalystEXCELLENT Based on 5 reviews Antonia Lombardi2024-09-24Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Dealing with anyone at Comprehensive has been great experience. They all go out of their way to help with any of the insurance questions and needs. I highly recommend one stop shop. Jonathan Kramer2024-09-23Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. It is a pleasure to work with a company that is incredibly responsive and always there to help with a personal touch. Ken Tuosto2024-09-18Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Comprehensive Ins had the best prices and the best part is they handle ALL my polices personal and business which makes it so much easier for me when i need service. Christopher Gallo2024-09-10Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Great customer service and rates


























Get an insurance quote to get started


Latest news & articles
